Unforeseen Incidents: Staying Vigilant Beyond the Risk Management Plan Parameters
You've probably heard someone that works in Risk Management speaking at great length about the importance of vigilance when it comes to cybersecurity. If not, thank you for allowing me to be the first.
The Importance Of Vigilance Beyond Risk Planning
Vigilance is very important when operating in a modern business setting. A threat actor must succeed only once to get what they want, whereas the defender needs to be right every single time. The odds are against us from the jump, and things are exacerbated even further when we understand the accepted risk of using some of even the most basic concepts in modern computing.
Modern life depends on dozens of interconnected technologies, including some you may never have heard of. You may have recently read about two significant cybersecurity incidents: a PHP vulnerability called PHP2shell and the compromise of eight intermediate TLS certificates from an internet service provider in India. If you’re not an engineer, these incidents may be difficult to understand.
To explain them, I’ll use an extremely timely and relevant reference: The Titanic.
The advertising for the Titanic in both Shipbuilder Magazine and Popular Mechanics, the Titanic was referred to as "practically unsinkable" because of the technological advancements that were employed in its design and building. While it was true that there were many new and robust technologies employed in its construction, we all know how unsinkable the Titanic actually was.
The sinking of the Titanic was not attributable to any one single event or action, nor was it a matter of design or execution, but it was instead a failure to plan as a result of hubris:
- The ship did not have enough lifeboats.
- The Titanic did not slow down when receiving multiple reports of ice in their area.
- The Titanic had been designed expecting the ship to hit an iceberg a single time straight on; however, the last-minute evasive maneuvers conducted by the ship resulted in a long gash consisting of multiple punctures.
As I said before, much of our lives in the modern world revolve around various interconnected technologies, much like The Titanic. We operate on the assumption that things will operate according to a specific plan.
How does this relate to security?
The Risk Outside Our Control
PHP. What is it? Without boring you with fascinating technical details, what you need to understand is that PHP is a programming language that many apps on the internet are written in. Typically, you expect these apps to do what they're written to do and that's it; however, this recent PHP2shell vulnerability enabled bad actors to execute code remotely, potentially compromising an application and allowing a bad actor to run all sorts of unwanted software.
In other recent cybersecurity news, it was found that a certificate authority in India had been issuing cryptographically weak SSL certificates for software. These kinds of certificates represent the kind of foundational trust that the internet and modern security is based on, so weak cryptography being associated with these keys is not ideal.
How weak was the encryption on these private keys? Typically, the kind of private key involved in this incident has 384 bits of entropy, allowing for 2^384 combinations, or a number with 116 digits. The private keys that were compromised were comprised of 1-3 digits. What are these keys for? They identify something as trustworthy. Websites have SSL certificates, and code can also be signed with an SSL certificate to verify its identity.
For context of importance, let's pretend that instead of security certificates, we're talking about driver’s licenses. Weak encryption for these kinds of certificates is akin to someone figuring out how to on demand create driver’s licenses that are legitimate driver’s licenses and passed background checks allowing them to take out loans or open bank accounts. To summarize, the risk with these weak certificates was a breakdown in the foundational trust that all modern infrastructure is built upon.
Practicing good security hygiene and building good habits is vitally important to existing in our modern word of interconnected technologies; however, even if you're right 100% of the time, you can still fall victim to security incidents outside of your control, because of these high stakes, it's even more important to maintain a high level of vigilance and awareness. It’s important that we do the right thing every time because as I said before: the bad actors only need to get it right once.
Chris Higgins is an information security engineer for Vizo Financial Corporate Credit Union. In this role, he provides incident response planning services, information security risk assessments, security awareness training, social engineering testing services, information security-related consulting and vulnerability testing and reporting services to credit unions. Chris has worked in the information technology and security field for 10 years, with another 10 years spent providing trend analytics and threat forecasting for the U.S. Department of Defense.